Reading is a thrill. I say this as someone who has jumped off 65 foot cliffs into rivers, backpacked into the wilderness, flown in small planes over the Himalayas, and fallen in love. Reading CAN be thrilling. Please read the first two entries of this blog to learn more about what I mean...
Saturday, July 10, 2010
Fahrenheit 451: The Authorized Adaption
Bradbury, Ray. Fahrenheit 451: the Authorized Adaptions. Illustrated and adapted by Tim Hamilton. (Graphic novel) Hill and Wang, 2009. ISBN 978-0-8090-5101-4
The beauty of Graphic Novels is that they can bring an entirely new dimension to stories that a simple text cannot convey. In one sense, it may be frustrating, as the reader may have imagined the story differently than the illustrator, and therefore has to struggle with his or her imagination being invaded by the images from another person's brain. However, if one can take it in stride, they will understand that while he or she has their own mental pictures attached to the text, it is also interesting to see a creative adaption form another point of view and, therefore, well worth the read. Another element of Graphic Novels is that they represent a different type of literacy. Not just a literacy of decoding words, but a literacy of images and symbols. Furthermore, it is an art form that can be appreciated in its own right.
These are several reasons why Ray Bradbury may have agreed to this adaption of his most famous novel, but the reason I am including this novel on my blog is because the Graphic Novel adaption will simply make it easier to read, and will make a great classic story within the comprehension grasp of middle readers.
There are a few parts of the dialogue that are somewhat difficult to follow, especially when the characters are speaking in riddles and quotes. However, in these instances, the illustrations convey the mood and setting, and the expressions on each face convey the emotions despite the confusing language. Furthermore, the story is broken into three concise sections that clearly carry the plot and help the reader understand when a transition or new phase is approaching.
There are several adult themes that may not be suitable for very young tweens (substance abuse, political oppression, war and violence) but due to the format and the adaption of the text, it is not as intense or as drawn out as the book. Tweens who already read Graphic Novels will most likely not find anything particularly offensive, and the dark consequences for said actions are clearly defined.
Labels:
classic,
futuristic,
graphic novels,
politics,
Ray Bradbury,
science fiction,
Tim Hamilton
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment